Smallholder Inclusion or Subordination? Power Relations, Value Distribution, and Social Sustainability in Dairy Goat Value Chains: A Systematic Review

Authors

  • Huda Ahmad Hudori Department of Agribusiness Management, Politeknik Negeri Jember
  • Siti Azizah Department af Animal Husbandry, Faculty of Animal Science and Technoloy, Universitas Brawijaya
  • Herly Evanuarini Department af Animal Husbandry, Faculty of Animal Science and Technoloy, Universitas Brawijaya
  • Ahmad Ridwan Department af Animal Husbandry, Faculty of Animal Science and Technoloy, Universitas Brawijaya
  • Rizal Perlambang CNAWP Department of Agribusiness Management, Politeknik Negeri Jember
  • Makmun Murod Graduate School, Department of Animal Nutrition and Feed Science, Universitas Gadjah Mada

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.62793/japsi.v3i3.137

Keywords:

Dairy goat value chains, Smallholder inclusion, Power relations, Value distribution, Social sustainability, Value-chain governance

Abstract

Smallholder participation in dairy goat value chains offers livelihood opportunities, but market integration does not necessarily ensure equitable benefits or producer autonomy. This systematic review examines how value-chain governance, economic relationships, and institutional arrangements shape smallholder inclusion and social sustainability. Following PRISMA 2020 guidelines, Scopus and Web of Science searches identified 52 records, with seven studies included after screening and full-text eligibility assessment. The review focused on original empirical research published from 2016 onward concerning dairy goat production, marketing, and value-chain relationships. Studies were concentrated in Spain, particularly Andalusia, and the broader Mediterranean context, covering diverse production systems and methodological approaches. Findings show that production intensity does not consistently increase profitability, while cooperative marketing supports income stability and market coordination. Short supply chains, direct sales, and artisanal processing offer greater pricing autonomy and value capture. However, dependence on external inputs, aging farming populations, labor shortages, and institutional constraints remain evident. A five-dimensional framework covering bargaining power, decision-making participation, market access, price-setting autonomy, and economic benefit distribution indicates that market participation may coexist with structural dependence. However, limited direct evidence on bargaining power and benefit distribution prevents definitive conclusions about producer subordination. This review provides a framework for distinguishing market participation from substantive inclusion and identifies evidence gaps for socially sustainable dairy goat value chains.

References

Birthal, P. S., Chand, R., Joshi, P. K., Saxena, R., Rajkhowa, P., Khan, M. T., Khan, M. A., & Chaudhary, K. R. (2017). Formal versus informal: Efficiency, inclusiveness and financing of dairy value chains in Indian Punjab. Journal of Rural Studies, 54, 288–303. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jrurstud.2017.06.009

Gërdoȩi, B., Skreli, E., Zhllima, E., & Imami, D. (2017). Determinants of long-term business relationships in the dairy value chain in transition countries: The case of Albania. Studies in Agricultural Economics, 119(3), 139–147. https://doi.org/10.7896/j.1709

German, L. A., Bonanno, A. M., Foster, L. C., & Cotula, L. (2020). “Inclusive business” in agriculture: Evidence from the evolution of agricultural value chains. In World Development (Vol. 134). Elsevier Ltd. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.worlddev.2020.105018

Kilelu, C., Klerkx, L., Omore, A., Baltenweck, I., Leeuwis, C., & Githinji, J. (2017). Value Chain Upgrading and the Inclusion of Smallholders in Markets: Reflections on Contributions of Multi-Stakeholder Processes in Dairy Development in Tanzania. European Journal of Development Research, 29(5), 1102–1121. https://doi.org/10.1057/s41287-016-0074-z

Lailia, N., Rondhi, M., & Soejono, D. (2020). ANALISIS RANTAI PASOK DAN STRATEGI PENGEMBANGAN SUSU KAMBING PASTEURISASI DI GOATZILLA FARM & CAFE. Forum Agribisnis, 10(1), 11–26. https://doi.org/10.29244/fagb.10.1.11-26

Linstädt, J., Thöne-Reineke, C., & Merle, R. (2024). Animal-based welfare indicators for dairy cows and their validity and practicality: a systematic review of the existing literature. In Frontiers in Veterinary Science (Vol. 11). Frontiers Media SA. https://doi.org/10.3389/fvets.2024.1429097

Lizarralde, J., Mandaluniz, N., Prat-Benhamou, A., Martín-Collado, D., Gaspar-García, P., Horrillo, A., Mancilla-Leytón, J. M., Mena, Y., Ruiz, R., & Soriano, B. (2026). Assessing resilience capacities of the Small Ruminant farms in Spain: A static approach thanks to field interviews. Small Ruminant Research, 256. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.smallrumres.2025.107688

Meza-Herrera, C. A., Navarrete-Molina, C., Macias-Cruz, U., Arellano-Rodriguez, G., De Santiago-Miramontes, A., Sariñana-Navarrete, M. A., Marin-Tinoco, R. I., & Perez-Marin, C. C. (2024). Dairy Goat Production Systems: A Comprehensive Analysis to Reframe Their Global Diversity. In Animals (Vol. 14, Number 24). Multidisciplinary Digital Publishing Institute (MDPI). https://doi.org/10.3390/ani14243717

Morales-Jerrett, E., Mena, Y., Camúñez-Ruiz, J. A., Fernández, J., & Mancilla-Leytón, J. M. (2022a). Characterization of dairy goat production systems using autochthonous breeds in Andalusia (Southern Spain): Classification and efficiency comparative analysis. Small Ruminant Research, 213. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.smallrumres.2022.106743

Morales-Jerrett, E., Mena, Y., Camúñez-Ruiz, J. A., Fernández, J., & Mancilla-Leytón, J. M. (2022b). Characterization of dairy goat production systems using autochthonous breeds in Andalusia (Southern Spain): Classification and efficiency comparative analysis. Small Ruminant Research, 213. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.smallrumres.2022.106743

Nyokabi, N. S., de Boer, I. J. M., Bijman, J., Bebe, B., Aguilar-Gallegos, N., Phelan, L., Lindahl, J., Bett, B., & Oosting, S. J. (2023). The role of power relationships, trust and social networks in shaping milk quality in Kenya. NJAS: Impact in Agricultural and Life Sciences, 95(1). https://doi.org/10.1080/27685241.2023.2194250

Wijers, G. D. M. (2019). Inequality regimes in Indonesian dairy cooperatives: understanding institutional barriers to gender equality. Agriculture and Human Values, 36(2), 167–181. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10460-018-09908-9

Downloads

Published

2026-11-22

How to Cite

Hudori, H. A., Azizah, S., Evanuarini, H., Ridwan, A., CNAWP, R. P., & Murod, M. (2026). Smallholder Inclusion or Subordination? Power Relations, Value Distribution, and Social Sustainability in Dairy Goat Value Chains: A Systematic Review. Journal of Agriprecision & Social Impact, 3(3). https://doi.org/10.62793/japsi.v3i3.137

Most read articles by the same author(s)

1 2 > >> 

Similar Articles

<< < 1 2 3 > >> 

You may also start an advanced similarity search for this article.